Picture this: It’s 10 p.m. on a Tuesday, your client wants expert video production with a 60-second explainer video by Friday, and you’re staring at an empty Google Doc, nursing a lukewarm coffee that tastes more like procrastination than Arabica beans. “Why not let AI whip up the script?” your exhausted brain suggests. After all, every ad in your feed promises that an algorithm can crank out “Hollywood-quality copy” in seconds. Tempting, right?

Sure—but be careful what you automate for. While machine-generated scripts can be a handy starting point, leaning on them too heavily can leave your video feeling more factory-assembled than heartfelt. Below are six reasons AI scriptwriting is great for robots yet, more often than not, terrible for humans—plus a few smart ways to harness the tech without losing your creative soul.

AI Speaks in Average, Not in Brand Voice

Algorithms learn by chewing through mountains of existing content and spitting out the statistical middle. That means an AI-generated script will sound suspiciously like everything else already floating around the internet. If your brand prides itself on a quirky personality, a local vernacular, or a distinctive sense of humor, the bot is unlikely to nail it out of the gate. You’ll end up sanding off your unique edges—the very edges that make viewers stop scrolling and pay attention.

Human workaround: Treat the AI draft as raw clay. Bring in a writer (maybe that’s you after a fresh cup of coffee) to inject on-brand tone, emotional nuance, and those inside jokes that only your audience gets.

Emotion Isn’t Just a Buzzword—It’s the Backbone

Good marketing scripts tug at heartstrings, spark curiosity, or make us laugh so hard we choke on popcorn. AI can mimic emotional language—the “story” and “value prop” buzzwords are always in its back pocket—but it doesn’t actually feel anything. The result is often copy that gestures toward emotion without ever landing it. Picture a rom-com trailer written by someone who’s read about love but never experienced it.

Human workaround: Have a real person vet each moment of the script for genuine emotional beats. Ask, “Would this line make an actual viewer smile, nod, or tear up?” If the answer feels lukewarm, rewrite until it’s visceral.

Context Is King, Queen, and Court Jester

Let’s say you’re producing a spot for a nonprofit serving bilingual communities in Miami. The AI writer knows plenty about “community impact” but has no lived experience with the cultural inside references that will resonate in Little Havana. It might default to clichés or, worse, inadvertently offend. Cultural nuance—dialects, local humor, subtle references—requires context no predictive model can fully grasp.

Human workaround: Involve people from the target community in the brainstorming and review process. Authenticity beats efficiency every time.

Legal and Ethical Minefields Still Need Human Brains

Generative models sometimes “hallucinate,” inventing statistics, quotes, or even brand slogans that don’t belong to you. If you blindly paste those lines into your final video, congratulations—you may have just invited a lawsuit. Copyrighted phrases, inaccurate claims, and unsubstantiated data can slip in unnoticed.

Human workaround: Fact-check everything like a journalism major on deadline. Verify quotes, study claims, and make sure the final script is as legally airtight as it is punchy. AI can assist, but the compliance burden sits squarely on the human side of the desk.

Structure Without Soul Is Still Soulless

AI typically follows a formula: hook, pain point, solution, call to action. That framework is fine until every video starts sounding like a PowerPoint template with a voice-over. You risk creative fatigue—both for your viewers and for your own team. A memorable piece of brand content often veers off script: an unexpected cold open, an awkward pause, a visual gag no algorithm would dare attempt.

Human workaround: Use AI for outlines or beat sheets, then break the rules like only a human storyteller can. Flip the chronology. Add a silent visual sequence. Hire a llama as a background extra because, well, your coffee brand is called “No Prob-llama.” AI won’t think of that.

Collaboration Is Where Magic Happens

Ask any seasoned director or DP, and they’ll tell you the best ideas usually emerge during hallway chats, rough-cut screenings, or on-set improvisation—moments when humans riff off each other’s energy. AI can’t lean over a monitor and say, “Wait, what if we try it handheld and in slow motion?” It can’t sense when the lead actor delivers a line so perfectly you decide to hold the shot for an extra beat. Scripts are living documents, and machine learning models don’t do “alive.”

Human workaround: Keep the writers’ room human, even if it’s a virtual Slack channel. Let AI generate alternatives—but let people decide which sparks fly.

Where AI Actually Shines (Yes, There’s Good News)

So, should we toss the robots out with yesterday’s cold brew? Not quite. Think of AI as the intern who never sleeps—great at grunt work but not yet ready to pitch to the client. Here are a few safe, time-saving tasks:

• Idea Kick-Starters: Need 20 headline variations or a bucketful of ad hooks? AI can brainstorm them in seconds, giving your team more clay to shape.
• SEO Ingredient List: Before you even open Final Draft, the algorithm can surface the keywords your audience is actually typing into YouTube. Handy blueprint, provided you still build the house.
• Scene Descriptions and Shot Lists: Some platforms will auto-generate b-roll suggestions and camera angles. Perfect for junior producers looking to get unstuck.
• Versioning & Localization: Swapping out slang for different regions or shortening a 30-second ad into a 15 can be a drag. Let the bot do a first pass, then finesse by hand.

Best Practices for a Balanced Workflow

If you want the speed of AI without sacrificing human storytelling, try this simple framework:

• Brief Like a Pro: Feed the AI clear parameters—brand voice, target audience, length, and objective. Garbage in, garbage out is as true today as it was in the early days of coding.
• Draft, Don’t Deliver: Consider the first AI output a “zero draft.” Print it, mark it up, and rewrite with wild abandon.
• Workshop With Real People: Table-read the script aloud. Have the motion graphics artist weigh in. Ask the social media manager whether that CTA will actually fly on TikTok.
• Layer in Human Checks: Legal review, sensitivity reads, fact-checking—these steps might feel old-school, but they save future headaches.
• Iterate Rapidly: Use AI again at later stages for alt lines, shorter tags, or A/B test intros. Think of it as a turbocharged thesaurus, not an autopilot button.

‍